Oil, fuel & driving calculator

Petrol vs diesel: which car is cheaper for your mileage?

Compares a petrol and a diesel version of the same car over the years you keep it: purchase price, fuel, AdBlue, servicing, tax and resale value. It finds the yearly mileage at which the diesel pays off and the CO₂ each one emits.

Editable share link Branded PDF report Free · no sign-up

Results

At 18,000 km a year the petrol car is 235 € cheaper over 6 years. The diesel only pays off above about 19,500 km a year.
6-year saving with the diesel
−€235
petrol cheaper overall
Break-even mileage
19,500 km/yr
yearly distance where both cost the same
Petrol total cost
€38,352
0.355 €/km
Diesel total cost
€38,587
0.357 €/km
Fuel per year: petrol
€2,142
1,224 L
Fuel + AdBlue per year: diesel
€1,655
972 L diesel + 22 L AdBlue
Fuel cost per 100 km
€11.90
diesel 9.19 €
CO₂ per year: petrol
2.8t
CO₂ per year: diesel
2.59t
8% less than petrol
Cumulative cost (resale credited in the last year)
Total cost vs yearly mileage

Year by year (before resale)

YearPetrol running (€)Diesel running (€)Petrol cumulative (€)Diesel cumulative (€)
13,4923,12533,49235,125
23,4923,12536,98438,249
33,4923,12540,47641,374
43,4923,12543,96844,498
53,4923,12547,46047,623
63,4923,12550,95250,747
  • Diesel has about 9% more energy per litre than petrol and diesel engines are more efficient at part load, so a diesel typically uses 15–25% fewer litres. But each litre of diesel emits more CO₂ (≈2.66 kg vs 2.29 kg), so the CO₂ gap is smaller than the fuel gap.
  • Modern diesels (Euro 6d) need AdBlue and a particle filter that must regenerate on longer drives. Mostly short urban trips can clog the filter, which is a real cost risk not captured in an average servicing figure.
  • Fuel prices are held constant. Low-emission zones may restrict older diesels in some cities.

How the petrol vs diesel calculator works

Diesel used to be the obvious choice for anyone who drove a lot. Today the answer is less clear: diesel versions cost more, modern exhaust treatment adds AdBlue and particulate filters, and resale values have softened in many markets. This calculator compares the petrol and diesel versions of the same car over the years you plan to keep it.

For each car it adds the purchase price, yearly fuel, servicing and wear, road tax and insurance, and for the diesel the AdBlue it consumes. At the end of the ownership period it credits the resale value as a percentage of the purchase price. It then works out the break-even mileage: the yearly distance at which both cars cost the same over that period.

It also shows CO₂ per year for each car, using the carbon content of the fuel rather than official test figures.

The formula

Total cost = price − resale + years × (fuel + AdBlue + servicing + tax & insurance) Fuel per year = km × L/100 km ÷ 100 × price per litre AdBlue per year = km ÷ 1000 × L per 1000 km × AdBlue price

Break-even km/yr = (capital difference + years × fixed-cost difference) ÷ (years × fuel saving per km) capital difference = (diesel price − diesel resale) − (petrol price − petrol resale)

CO₂ = litres × 2.29 kg (petrol) or 2.66 kg (diesel)

Worked example

The defaults describe a mid-size car kept for 6 years and driven 18,000 km a year.

Petrol: costs 30,000, uses 6.8 L/100 km at 1.75 per litre, so 1,224 litres or 2,142 a year in fuel. Servicing is 450 and tax plus insurance 900 a year. After six years it resells for 42% (12,600). Total cost: 30,000 − 12,600 + 6 × 3,492 = 38,352, or 0.355 per km.

Diesel: costs 32,000, uses 5.4 L/100 km at 1.68 per litre, so 972 litres or 1,633 a year, plus 22 litres of AdBlue (about 22). Fuel and AdBlue together come to 1,655 a year. Servicing is 520 and tax plus insurance 950. Resale is 38% (12,160). Total: 32,000 − 12,160 + 6 × 3,125 = 38,587, or 0.357 per km.

The petrol car comes out 235 cheaper. The diesel saves about 490 a year on fuel, and about 370 a year after its higher servicing and tax, but it loses 2,440 more in depreciation. The break-even is about 19,500 km a year. At 35,000 km a year the diesel would be roughly 2,500 cheaper over six years.

On emissions the petrol car releases 2.80 t of CO₂ a year and the diesel 2.59 t, 8% less, even though it burns 21% fewer litres.

How to read the results

  • Saving with the diesel is the difference in total cost; a negative value means petrol is cheaper.
  • Break-even mileage is the most useful number. If you drive well above it, choose diesel; well below, choose petrol.
  • The mileage chart shows both total-cost lines crossing at break-even, which makes it easy to see how much margin you have.
  • The cumulative chart drops in the last year when resale value is credited.

Typical values

Item Petrol Diesel
Real-world consumption, mid-size car 6–8 L/100 km 4.5–6.5 L/100 km
Energy per litre (LHV) about 33 MJ about 36 MJ
CO₂ per litre burned 2.29 kg 2.66 kg
Price premium for the car — often 1,500–3,000
AdBlue use (cars) — 0.8–1.5 L per 1,000 km

Tips for choosing

  • Use your real mileage. Look at the last two MOT or service records rather than guessing.
  • Think about trip length. If most journeys are under 15–20 km, the particulate filter may not regenerate properly. Petrol or a hybrid is safer.
  • Check local rules. Low-emission zones in many European cities restrict older diesels, which hits resale value.
  • Price the actual versions you would buy. The premium for the diesel varies a lot between models and markets.
  • Consider the alternatives. A full hybrid often matches diesel economy in town; compare it with the hybrid vs petrol calculator, an LPG conversion or an electric car.

For one-off trip costs use the fuel cost calculator, and to convert mpg figures from reviews see the fuel economy converter.

Limitations

Fuel prices and servicing costs are held constant over the ownership period, and financing is not included. Resale is a single percentage, which cannot capture sudden market shifts such as new city bans. Average servicing figures do not include the risk of a large repair (particulate filter, EGR valve, injectors, dual-mass flywheel), which is more likely on diesels driven mostly in town. CO₂ is tank-to-wheel; it does not count fuel production, nor the higher nitrogen oxide emissions of older diesels, which affect air quality rather than climate.

Method & assumptions

Total cost = price − resale + years × (fuel + AdBlue + servicing + tax/insurance). Fuel = km × L/100 km ÷ 100 × price. Break-even mileage solves petrol cost = diesel cost for yearly km: (capital difference + years × fixed-cost difference) ÷ (years × per-km fuel saving). CO₂ = litres × IPCC tank-to-wheel factor (petrol 2.29 kg/L, diesel 2.66 kg/L).

Frequently asked questions

Is a diesel or petrol car cheaper to run?
A diesel burns 15–25% fewer litres than an equivalent petrol car, but it usually costs more to buy, needs AdBlue and has pricier servicing. With the default inputs, at 18,000 km a year the two cost almost the same over six years; the diesel only wins above roughly 19,500 km a year.
How many km a year make a diesel worth it?
It depends on the price gap between the two versions and on fuel prices, but break-even usually lands between 15,000 and 25,000 km a year. Below that the petrol car is normally cheaper; well above it, as for sales reps or taxi drivers, diesel still saves money.
Does a diesel emit less CO₂ than petrol?
Per kilometre, slightly less. Diesel engines use fewer litres, but each litre of diesel releases about 2.66 kg of CO₂ against 2.29 kg for petrol. In the default example the diesel emits 8% less CO₂ while using 21% fewer litres.
What is AdBlue and how much does it cost?
AdBlue is a urea solution injected into the exhaust of modern diesels to cut nitrogen oxides. Cars use about 0.8–1.5 litres per 1,000 km, so at around 1 per litre it adds roughly 15–25 a year for typical mileage.
Are diesels bad for short trips?
Mostly short urban trips are hard on a modern diesel. The particulate filter needs regular hot running to burn off soot, and if it cannot regenerate it can clog, which can mean an expensive repair. Low-mileage town drivers are usually better off with petrol or a hybrid.
Do diesel cars lose value faster?
In many European markets diesel resale values have weakened since 2015 because of emissions scandals, low-emission zones and talk of bans. The calculator lets you set a lower resale percentage for the diesel to reflect your local used-car prices.

Sources & references

  1. IPCC 2006 Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Vol. 2, Ch. 1
  2. US DOE / EPA fueleconomy.gov: Diesel vehicles
  3. US DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center: Fuel properties comparison

Embed this calculator

Free for blogs, installers, schools and NGOs. Copy the code below; it updates itself automatically.