How to judge an energy-saving measure
Most efficiency projects are judged on one number, simple payback, and many good ones are rejected because of it. A measure that pays back in four years but lasts twenty is often a better investment than one that pays back in two and lasts five. This calculator gives the payback figures managers ask for, plus the measures finance teams use: net present value (NPV), internal rate of return (IRR), savings-to-investment ratio (SIR) and the cost of each kWh saved.
It works for any measure whose benefit is lower energy use: lighting, motors and drives, insulation, controls, heat recovery, compressed-air repairs, boiler upgrades. Fuel savings can be entered in kWh with the fuel price per kWh.
The formula
Simple payback = net investment ÷ first-year net saving NPV = Σ cash flow_t ÷ (1 + r)^t IRR = r at which NPV = 0 SIR = PV(savings) ÷ net investment Cost of saved energy = (net investment × CRF(r, life) + maintenance change) ÷ annual kWh CRF(r, n) = r(1 + r)^n ÷ ((1 + r)^n − 1)
Worked example
The defaults describe a 25,000 investment that saves 60,000 kWh a year at 0.15 per kWh, with 2% yearly price escalation, a 0.5% yearly decline in savings, a 12-year life and a 7% discount rate.
- First-year saving: 60,000 × 0.15 = 9,000, so simple payback is 2.8 years. Discounting stretches it to 3.1 years.
- Over 12 years the measure saves about 700 MWh. The NPV is about 51,700 and the IRR 36%.
- SIR is 3.1: every unit invested returns about three in present-value savings.
- Cost of saved energy: 25,000 × CRF(7%, 12) = 3,148 a year, divided by 60,000 kWh, gives 0.052 per kWh, about a third of the energy price.
The LED preset adds 1,500 a year of avoided lamp replacements and cuts the payback to 2.4 years. The insulation preset has a 5.9-year payback but a 30-year life, giving an IRR of 19% and an NPV comparable to the LED project. The building-controls preset shows the effect of savings that decline 3% a year.
Typical paybacks
| Measure | Typical simple payback | Typical life |
|---|---|---|
| Compressed-air leak repair | weeks to months | 1–2 years (repeat) |
| LED lighting retrofit | 1–4 years | 10–15 years |
| Variable-speed drive on pump/fan | 1–3 years | 10–15 years |
| Building controls / BMS tuning | 1–3 years | 5–10 years |
| Premium-efficiency motor (at failure) | 1–3 years (incremental cost) | 15–20 years |
| Heat recovery | 2–5 years | 15–20 years |
| Roof or wall insulation | 4–10 years | 30+ years |
How to read the results
- Simple payback is easy to communicate but ignores everything after it.
- NPV is the value the project creates in today’s money; any positive value beats leaving the cash at the discount rate.
- IRR lets you compare the project with other uses of capital.
- Cost of saved energy is the cleanest comparison with the energy price and with supply-side options. Compare it with the LCOE of new generation: efficiency is often the cheapest “power plant”.
- The cumulative chart shows when the project breaks even, with and without discounting.
Limitations
Cash flows are pre-tax and unlevered; tax depreciation, interest and inflation are not modelled separately (treat the discount rate and escalation as real or nominal consistently). Savings estimates are often optimistic, so verify with metering. Rebound effects and interactions between measures (for example, LEDs reducing cooling load but increasing heating) are not included. For full project finance with debt and tax, use the NPV and IRR calculator.
Method & assumptions
Year-t cash flow = kWh saved × (1 − decline)t−1 × price × (1 + escalation)t−1 − maintenance change; year 0 = −(investment − grants). Simple payback = net investment ÷ first-year saving. Discounted payback, NPV and IRR use the discount rate on these cash flows. SIR = PV of savings ÷ net investment. Cost of saved energy = (net investment × CRF(rate, life) + maintenance change) ÷ annual kWh.
Frequently asked questions
How do I calculate the payback of an energy efficiency project?
What is a good payback period for energy efficiency?
What is the cost of saved energy?
What is the savings-to-investment ratio (SIR)?
Should I include energy price escalation?
How do I know the savings are real?
Sources & references
Embed this calculator
Free for blogs, installers, schools and NGOs. Copy the code below; it updates itself automatically.