Electricity & grids guide

Demand Response Explained: Paying Users to Shift Load

How demand response works: time-of-use tariffs, peak events, industrial load shedding, smart EV charging and virtual power plants, with real programme numbers.

Updated 6 min read 1,293 words

For a century, grids were run on one assumption: demand is whatever it is, and supply must follow. Demand response turns that around. Instead of starting another gas turbine for the two hottest hours of the year, the operator pays some customers to use less in those hours. The cheapest megawatt is often the one nobody consumes. With solar flooding grids at midday and EVs, heat pumps and data centres adding load, flexible demand has moved from a niche tool for heavy industry to a core part of how modern systems stay balanced and affordable.

The problem demand response solves

Grids are built for the peak. A system that averages 12 GW but peaks at 18 GW needs enough generation, transmission and distribution for those 18 GW, even if the top 10% of that capacity runs only a few dozen hours a year. Those peaking assets are expensive per kWh delivered. Shaving a few percent off the peak can avoid building them altogether.

There is a second, newer problem: timing. Solar output peaks at noon, while household demand peaks in the evening. Moving flexible loads into the solar hours absorbs surplus energy that would otherwise be curtailed and lowers the evening ramp. See Baseload, Peaking and Flexibility for how that ramp shapes the generation mix.

Types of demand response

Type How it works Typical participants Response time
Time-of-use (ToU) tariffs Fixed cheaper and dearer hours Households, businesses Habit, every day
Dynamic / real-time pricing Price follows wholesale market hourly or every 15 min Households with smart meters, EV owners Automated, hourly
Critical peak pricing Very high price on a few announced days Commercial, some households Day-ahead notice
Peak-time rebates Payment for reducing below a baseline during events Households Hours ahead
Direct load control Utility cycles air conditioners or water heaters Households Minutes
Interruptible contracts Large user cuts load on request for a discount Smelters, cement, data centres Minutes to hours
Reserve and capacity market bids Aggregated loads sold like a generator Aggregators, VPPs Seconds to hours

Price-based schemes (the first four) rely on customers reacting to a signal. Incentive-based schemes pay for a promise to deliver a reduction when called.

How big is it?

The numbers are larger than most people expect. FERC’s annual assessments have counted roughly 30 GW of demand response enrolled across US wholesale markets in recent years, equal to around 6% of their combined peak demand. Retail utility programmes add more on top. PJM, the largest US market, regularly clears several gigawatts of demand response in its capacity auctions, where it competes directly with power plants.

Europe lags, partly because many national rules long made it hard for aggregators to bid loads into markets. The EU’s 2019 electricity directive required member states to open their markets to demand-side participation, and France, Belgium, Finland and Great Britain now have active aggregator sectors. Australia launched a Wholesale Demand Response Mechanism in October 2021 that lets large users sell reductions into the National Electricity Market; registered volumes remained small in its first years, under 100 MW.

Households: the Demand Flexibility Service

The clearest demonstration of household flexibility came from Great Britain in winter 2022/23. Facing a possible gas shortage, the system operator launched the Demand Flexibility Service. Suppliers signed up customers with smart meters and paid them for every kWh they cut below their normal usage during one- to two-hour evening events. Around 1.6 million households and businesses took part, and across 22 events they delivered about 3.3 GWh of reductions, according to the operator. Peak reductions reached several hundred megawatts, comparable to a mid-sized power station. The service has run each winter since.

The lesson: ordinary households will respond if the signal is simple and the payment is visible, especially when apps automate the response.

Industry, data centres and bitcoin miners

Big electricity users have always been the backbone of demand response. Aluminium smelters, electric arc furnaces, cement mills, chlor-alkali plants and water pumping stations can often drop tens of megawatts at short notice. In Texas, crypto-mining companies signed up as controllable loads. In August 2023, during a heatwave, one large miner reported earning about US$31.7 million in power credits from ERCOT for curtailing its operations, more than the value of the bitcoin it would have mined. Data centres are the next frontier. Their load can be moved between sites or delayed for some batch computing, and grid operators facing rapid data-centre growth are now asking whether new connections can be made flexible.

Smart charging and virtual power plants

EVs are an ideal flexible load. A car parked for 10–12 hours overnight needs perhaps 3–5 hours of charging, so a smart charger can choose the cheapest or cleanest hours. Several UK and Australian suppliers offer EV tariffs with off-peak rates a third or less of the standard price. With vehicle-to-grid, the car can also export power at the peak, as covered in our EV charging guide.

A virtual power plant aggregates thousands of these devices. South Australia’s VPP programmes, Tesla’s and Octopus’s schemes in Britain and utility thermostat programmes in the US already dispatch hundreds of megawatts. To the grid, a VPP looks like a single plant that can ramp in seconds.

A worked example: shifting EV charging

Daily EV energy: 40 km/day × 0.17 kWh/km ≈ 6.8 kWh Peak rate (illustrative): 0.30 per kWh; off-peak rate: 0.12 per kWh

Charging at peak: 6.8 × 0.30 = 2.04 per day → 745 per year Charging off-peak: 6.8 × 0.12 = 0.82 per day → 298 per year Saving from shifting: ≈ 447 per year, with the same energy used

Swap in your own rates with the EV charging cost calculator, and check which appliances are worth moving with the appliance energy cost calculator.

Demand response in Malaysia

Malaysia’s hot climate makes air conditioning the dominant household and commercial peak load, and it is a good candidate for pre-cooling and thermostat control. Commercial and industrial customers in Peninsular Malaysia have long had peak and off-peak tariffs. The tariff structure TNB introduced on 1 July 2025 added an optional time-of-use scheme for domestic customers, with a weekday peak window in the afternoon and evening and cheaper off-peak hours. Rates and hours can change, so check the current figures on our TNB tariff page. Estimate what your air conditioner costs to run at different times with the air conditioner cost calculator.

Limits and pitfalls

  • Baselines. Paying for “reductions” requires guessing what a customer would have used anyway. Poor baselines reward people for doing nothing and invite gaming.
  • Rebound. Shifted load comes back later. If thousands of water heaters restart at the same minute after an event, they can create a new peak.
  • Comfort and production limits. Buildings can pre-cool for an hour or two, not a whole day. Factories lose output if they curtail too often.
  • Equity. Dynamic tariffs reward those who can shift, often households with EVs, batteries and flexible schedules. Poorly designed schemes can raise costs for others.

The short version

Demand response pays people to use electricity at better times. It ranges from a cheap night rate to automated fleets of batteries and EVs that bid into markets like power stations. It cuts peak capacity needs, absorbs midday solar and makes forced outages rarer. For a household, the practical steps are simple: find out whether you have a time-of-use option, move big loads into cheap hours, and let smart devices do the switching. To see how your tariff is built, read How to Read Your Electricity Bill.

Calculators for this topic

Frequently asked questions

What is demand response in simple terms?
Demand response means electricity users cut or move their consumption when the grid is stressed or power is expensive, and get paid or save money for doing it. It can be as simple as running a dishwasher at night on a time-of-use tariff, or as large as a smelter switching off a potline for an hour.
How much money can a household make from demand response?
Usually modest sums. In Great Britain's Demand Flexibility Service, households typically earned a few pounds per event in winter 2022/23. Bigger savings come from permanently shifting large loads such as EV charging, water heating or air conditioning into cheap hours on a time-of-use tariff.
What is the difference between load shifting and load shedding?
Load shifting moves consumption to another time, so total energy use stays about the same, for example pre-cooling a building before the peak. Load shedding simply drops consumption during an event, such as a factory stopping a process. Grid operators value both, but shifting is easier for most customers.
Does Malaysia have time-of-use electricity tariffs?
Yes. Under the tariff structure TNB introduced in Peninsular Malaysia on 1 July 2025, domestic customers can opt for a time-of-use scheme with a peak period on weekday afternoons and evenings and cheaper off-peak hours. Commercial and industrial customers have had peak and off-peak tariffs for longer. Check TNB for current rates and hours.
What is a virtual power plant?
A virtual power plant (VPP) is software that pools many small devices, such as home batteries, EV chargers, heat pumps or thermostats, and dispatches them together as if they were one power station. VPPs bid into wholesale, reserve or capacity markets and share the revenue with the device owners.
Is demand response the same as a blackout?
No. Demand response is voluntary and planned: customers agree in advance to reduce use in return for payment or lower prices. Rotating outages are involuntary cuts imposed by the grid operator when there is not enough supply. Good demand response programmes make forced outages less likely.

Sources & references

  1. FERC: Assessment of Demand Response and Advanced Metering (annual staff report)
  2. NESO: Demand Flexibility Service
  3. AEMO: Wholesale Demand Response Mechanism
  4. IEA: Demand Response tracking
  5. Tenaga Nasional Berhad: Electricity tariff and time-of-use information

Figures in this guide are typical ranges drawn from the sources above; your own numbers depend on location, prices and equipment. Use the linked calculators for site-specific estimates.