Electricity & grids guide

Baseload, Peaking and Flexibility: How Grids Plan Supply

What baseload, mid-merit and peaking plants are, ramp rates and minimum loads by technology, the duck curve, and why flexibility now matters more than baseload.

Updated 5 min read 1,235 words

Ask an engineer from the 1990s how to plan a power system and you would hear about three layers. Baseload plants ran day and night. Mid-merit plants followed the daily rise and fall. Peakers came on for the hottest afternoons or coldest evenings. That model fitted a world of coal, nuclear and gas, where the only thing that varied was demand. Wind and solar have added a second source of variability on the supply side, and the old layers are being reshuffled. This guide explains the classic terms, the technical limits of each plant type, and why “flexibility” has replaced “baseload” as the word planners care about most.

Reading a load curve

Demand on a grid follows a strong daily pattern. In a temperate country it is lowest around 3–5 am, rises through the morning, plateaus during working hours and peaks in the early evening when lighting, cooking and heating overlap. In hot countries like Malaysia, air conditioning pushes the peak into the afternoon. Weekends are lower, and there are seasonal swings driven by temperature.

Sort every hour of a year from highest to lowest demand and you get a load duration curve. Its shape tells you how much capacity is needed for how many hours:

Band Hours per year needed Classic plant Why
Baseload 6,000–8,760 Nuclear, coal, lignite, run-of-river hydro High capital cost, low fuel cost, best run constantly
Mid-merit (intermediate) 2,000–6,000 Combined-cycle gas, newer coal Moderate costs, can follow daily swings
Peaking Under 1,000–2,000 Open-cycle gas, gas engines, oil, reservoir hydro Cheap to build, costly to run, fast start

The logic is economic. A plant with high fixed costs and low fuel costs needs to run many hours to be cheap per kWh. A plant with low fixed costs can afford to sit idle most of the year. The capacity factor of each band follows directly; test it with the capacity factor calculator.

How flexible are different plants?

Every thermal plant has physical limits: how fast it can change output (ramp rate), how low it can go before it must shut down (minimum stable load) and how long it takes to start. Typical values from IEA and Agora Energiewende studies:

Technology Ramp rate (% of capacity per min) Minimum stable load Hot start time
Nuclear (load following, e.g. French PWRs) 2–5% within 50–100% band ~50% Many hours to days from cold
Lignite 1–2% 40–60% (older), ~35% (retrofitted) 2–6 h
Hard coal 1.5–4% 25–40% 2–4 h
Combined-cycle gas (CCGT) 2–8% 30–50% 30–90 min
Open-cycle gas turbine (OCGT) 8–15% 20–50% 5–15 min
Gas engines 15–20%+ ~10–30% per engine Under 5 min
Reservoir hydro Up to full output within minutes Low Minutes
Battery storage 0 to 100% in under 1 s None Instant

Ranges vary with plant age and design. Older coal plants are much stiffer than retrofitted ones, and Danish and German coal plants were modified in the 2010s to run down to 20–25% load as wind grew. France routinely varies nuclear output: its reactors were designed to follow load because nuclear supplies around two-thirds of French electricity. See How a Nuclear Reactor Works for the physics behind that.

Net load and the duck curve

With wind and solar on the grid, what thermal plants actually have to supply is net load: demand minus variable renewable output. On a sunny spring day in California, net load falls sharply after sunrise, bottoms out around midday and then climbs steeply as the sun sets and people come home.

The California Independent System Operator (CAISO) first published its “duck curve” chart in 2013 as a forecast. Reality overshot it. Midday net load has fallen far below the original projections on spring days, and the evening ramp, the climb from the midday low to the evening peak, has exceeded 20 GW within about three hours on some days. Batteries changed the picture from 2020 onwards: California went from almost no grid storage to well over 10 GW of batteries by 2024, much of it charging at noon and discharging into the evening ramp.

Evening ramp example (illustrative) Net load at 15:00 = 30 GW demand − 16 GW solar = 14 GW Net load at 19:00 = 36 GW demand − 0.5 GW solar = 35.5 GW Ramp = 21.5 GW over 4 h ≈ 90 MW per minute

At 3% per minute, a 500 MW CCGT adds 15 MW/min, so the ramp alone needs about 6 such units ramping flat out, or batteries.

Why “baseload” is losing its meaning

When wind and solar have near-zero running cost, they are dispatched first. In sunny or windy hours, there may be no room left for a plant that wants to run at constant output. The grid then has a choice: curtail renewables, throttle the inflexible plant, export, store or find new demand. In South Australia, rooftop and utility solar have at times supplied more than 100% of the state’s demand on spring middays, and minimum operational demand has fallen below zero on some days.

None of this means firm capacity has stopped mattering. A grid still needs enough dependable supply for a cold, still evening or a cloudy week. What has changed is the job description. The valuable resources are the ones that can:

  • ramp quickly from low to high output,
  • start and stop often without damage,
  • run economically at low capacity factors,
  • shift energy in time (storage),
  • or change demand (see Demand Response Explained).

Planners now talk about firm, flexible and variable resources instead of baseload, mid-merit and peak.

Flexibility toolbox

Source of flexibility Timescale Notes
Batteries Seconds to ~4 hours Fastest, falling costs, limited duration
Pumped hydro Hours to days Large, site-limited; see Hydropower Explained
Reservoir hydro Hours to seasons Excellent where available
Gas turbines and engines Minutes to weeks Flexible but fossil and exposed to gas prices
Interconnectors Minutes to seasons Share weather across regions
Demand response Minutes to hours Cheap if programmes are well designed
Retrofitted thermal plants Hours Lower minimum loads, faster ramps

The picture in Malaysia

Peninsular Malaysia’s grid has been dominated by coal and gas, with coal units supplying much of the steady base and gas plants following load. Peak demand has climbed with economic growth and air conditioning use, reaching about 19–20 GW in recent years according to Grid System Operator data, with the peak typically on hot weekday afternoons. As large-scale solar and rooftop solar expand under the national roadmap, the afternoon peak will be partly met by solar and the stress will move to the early evening, the same shift seen in California and Australia. Plans for battery storage and flexible gas capacity reflect that. Read more in How Malaysia’s Electricity System Works and on the Malaysia electricity page.

In practice

  • Baseload, mid-merit and peaking describe how many hours a plant is economic to run, not a fixed property of the technology.
  • Ramp rates and minimum loads limit how well thermal plants work alongside wind and solar.
  • Net load, not demand, is what dispatchable plants must follow, and its evening ramp is the new design challenge.
  • Flexibility from storage, hydro, interconnectors and demand is now worth more than constant output.

To compare what each technology costs per MWh over its life, try the LCOE calculator and read LCOE Explained.

Calculators for this topic

Frequently asked questions

What is baseload power?
Baseload is the minimum level of demand on a grid over a day or year, and by extension the plants that run almost continuously to meet it. Traditionally that meant nuclear, coal, lignite and run-of-river hydro, which have low running costs and prefer steady output.
What is a peaking power plant?
A peaker is a plant that runs only when demand is highest, often a few hundred hours a year or less. Open-cycle gas turbines, gas engines, oil-fired units and, increasingly, batteries fill this role. They are cheap to build but expensive per kWh because their fixed costs are spread over so few hours.
Do we still need baseload plants with lots of solar and wind?
Grids still need firm capacity that is available when wind and sun are low, but they need less output that runs flat out around the clock. What becomes valuable is flexibility: plants, storage and demand that can ramp up and down quickly and run at varying levels.
What is the duck curve?
The duck curve is the shape of net load (demand minus solar and wind) on a sunny day in a solar-heavy grid. Net load dips at midday when solar peaks, forming the duck's belly, then climbs steeply in the evening as the sun sets, forming its neck. California's grid operator made the term famous.
How fast can different power plants ramp?
Roughly, as a share of rated output per minute: batteries go from zero to full in under a second; open-cycle gas turbines ramp around 8–15% per minute; modern combined-cycle plants 2–8%; hard coal 1.5–4%; lignite 1–2%; and nuclear plants designed for load following, as in France, about 2–5% within their operating band.
What is minimum stable load?
It is the lowest output at which a thermal plant can run continuously without shutting down, typically 25–40% of capacity for coal, 30–50% for combined-cycle gas and around 50% for nuclear in load-following mode. Below that, the plant must switch off, and restarting can take hours.

Sources & references

  1. IEA (2018). Status of Power System Transformation: Power plant flexibility
  2. Agora Energiewende (2017). Flexibility in thermal power plants
  3. CAISO: What the duck curve tells us about managing a green grid / Today's Outlook data
  4. OECD-NEA (2011). Technical and Economic Aspects of Load Following with Nuclear Power Plants
  5. Grid System Operator Malaysia: system data

Figures in this guide are typical ranges drawn from the sources above; your own numbers depend on location, prices and equipment. Use the linked calculators for site-specific estimates.