Heating & gas calculator

How much will a new condensing boiler save?

Compares your old gas, LPG or oil boiler with a new condensing one: fuel saved per year, money saved, payback and CO₂. Accounts for the flow temperature, because a condensing boiler running at 75–80 °C barely condenses.

Editable share link Branded PDF report Free · no sign-up

Results

Going from 78% to about 92% efficiency with better controls cuts fuel use by 20%, saving 365 € a year. The boiler pays back in 9.6 years; over 15 years you come out 2,820 € ahead.
Saving per year
€365
20% less fuel
Payback
9.6 years
Net gain over 15 years
€2,820
with 2% a year fuel price growth
Fuel saved per year
3,655kWh
from 18,000 to 14,345 kWh
Old boiler efficiency
78%
New boiler efficiency
92%
at 55 °C flow
CO₂ saved per year
738kg
Useful heat (unchanged)
14,040kWh/yr
Cumulative net saving
Yearly saving by flow temperature
  • Condensing boilers recover heat from the water vapour in the flue gas, but only when the return water is cooler than the dew point (about 55 °C for natural gas, 47–48 °C for oil). Many are installed and left at 75–80 °C flow, where they work like a good non-condensing boiler.
  • Efficiencies are seasonal net values typical of field trials, a few points below lab ratings. Lowering the flow temperature on an existing condensing boiler, often to 50–55 °C, is a free saving worth trying before replacing anything.

How this boiler savings calculator works

Your house needs the same amount of heat whatever boiler makes it. What changes with a new boiler is how much fuel it burns to deliver that heat. The calculator starts from your yearly fuel use and the old boiler’s seasonal efficiency to find the useful heat your home actually receives, then works out how much fuel a new condensing boiler would need for the same heat.

The new boiler’s efficiency depends on two things: the fuel and the flow temperature. A condensing boiler squeezes extra heat out of the water vapour in its flue gas, but only when the return water is cool enough for the vapour to condense, below about 55 °C for natural gas and 47–48 °C for oil. At a 75–80 °C flow it hardly condenses at all. So the calculator uses lower seasonal efficiencies at higher flow temperatures. Optional smart or weather-compensating controls cut heat demand by about 6%, in line with the 4–8% range usually quoted.

The formula

Useful heat = fuel per year × energy per unit × old efficiency New fuel = useful heat × controls factor ÷ new efficiency ÷ energy per unit Controls factor = 0.94 with smart / weather compensation, else 1

New efficiency (gas) = 95 / 92 / 89 / 86% at 45 / 55 / 65 / 75 °C flow Saving = (old fuel − new fuel) × price Payback = installed cost ÷ first-year saving Net gain = Σ savings with yearly price growth − installed cost

Energy per unit is 1 for gas billed in kWh, 7.1 kWh per litre for LPG and 10.0 kWh per litre for heating oil.

Worked example

The defaults describe a gas-heated home using 18,000 kWh a year with a 1990s–2000s non-condensing boiler (78% seasonal efficiency). The new condensing boiler will run at a 55 °C flow with weather-compensating controls, costs €3,500 installed, and gas costs €0.10/kWh, rising 2% a year.

  • Useful heat: 18,000 × 0.78 = 14,040 kWh.
  • New gas use: 14,040 × 0.94 ÷ 0.92 ≈ 14,345 kWh.
  • Gas saved: about 3,655 kWh a year (20%), worth €365 in the first year.
  • Payback: €3,500 ÷ €365 ≈ 9.6 years.
  • Over a 15-year boiler life, with prices growing 2% a year, you end up about €2,820 ahead.
  • CO₂ saved: 3,655 × 0.202 ≈ 740 kg a year.

The flow temperature chart shows how much the setting matters. At 45 °C the same boiler saves about €411 a year; left at 75–80 °C, only about €265.

How to read the results

  • Saving per year is the first-year figure at today’s price.
  • Payback is simple payback on the full installed cost. If you must replace a broken boiler anyway, divide only the extra cost of the better option by the saving.
  • Net gain over the lifetime includes fuel price growth but no discounting or maintenance changes.
  • Useful heat (unchanged) is your home’s real heat need, the number to use when sizing a new boiler or a heat pump.

Typical values

Boiler Typical seasonal efficiency
Cast iron, pre-1980, standing pilot 55–70%
Non-condensing, 1990s–2000s 70–80%
Condensing at 75–80 °C flow 85–88%
Condensing at 50–55 °C flow 90–93%
Condensing with underfloor heating (35–45 °C) 93–96%
Fuel Energy per unit CO₂ per kWh of fuel
Natural gas per kWh on the bill 0.202 kg
LPG about 7.1 kWh per litre 0.227 kg
Heating oil about 10 kWh per litre 0.267 kg

Tips to get the most from a new boiler

  • Turn the flow temperature down. It is a free saving on any condensing boiler, old or new; try 55 °C and lower it further if rooms stay warm.
  • Fit weather compensation. It lowers the flow temperature automatically in mild weather, when most of the season’s heat is used.
  • Balance the radiators so the return water comes back cool.
  • Do not oversize. A boiler much bigger than the real peak load cycles on and off and loses efficiency. Use degree days to estimate the peak.
  • Compare the alternatives. Before committing for 15 years, check heat pump vs gas boiler and heating cost comparison. Oil users can see their tank and delivery numbers in the heating oil cost calculator.

Limitations

Efficiencies are typical seasonal values from field experience, not the lab figures on the box, and individual installations vary by several points. The old boiler’s efficiency is the biggest uncertainty: if you overestimate how bad it is, you overestimate the saving. Fuel prices, grants, servicing costs and the value of a more reliable system are not modelled beyond the inputs. The calculator compares boilers of the same fuel and does not cover switching fuels.

Method & assumptions

Useful heat = current fuel × energy per unit × old efficiency. New fuel = useful heat × controls factor (0.94 with smart / weather compensation) ÷ new efficiency. New efficiency depends on the fuel and flow temperature (e.g. gas 95 / 92 / 89 / 86% at 45 / 55 / 65 / 75 °C). Saving = (old − new fuel) × price; payback = installed cost ÷ first-year saving; net gain sums savings with price growth minus cost.

Frequently asked questions

How much will a new condensing boiler save?
Replacing a non-condensing boiler of around 78% seasonal efficiency with a condensing one at about 92% cuts fuel use by roughly 15%, and by about 20% with better controls. On 18,000 kWh of gas a year at €0.10/kWh that is around €365 a year.
How long does a new boiler take to pay back?
Usually 7–15 years on fuel savings alone, depending on how inefficient the old boiler is, how much fuel you use and the fuel price. Very old boilers (65–72%) and oil or LPG systems pay back fastest. Most people replace a boiler when the old one fails, and then only the extra cost of the better model matters.
Why is my condensing boiler not condensing?
Because the water coming back from the radiators is too hot. A gas condensing boiler only recovers the latent heat in the flue gas when the return water is below about 55 °C. Many are left at the factory setting of 75–80 °C flow, where they work like a good non-condensing boiler.
What flow temperature should I set on a condensing boiler?
As low as keeps the house comfortable, often 50–55 °C for radiators in winter and lower in mild weather. Weather compensation does this automatically. With underfloor heating or oversized radiators, 35–45 °C is possible and gives the highest efficiency.
What efficiency does an old boiler have?
Cast-iron boilers from before about 1980 often manage 55–70% seasonal efficiency, non-condensing boilers from the 1990s and 2000s typically 70–80%, and modern condensing boilers 88–94% in real homes, a few points below their lab ratings.
Should I replace my boiler with a heat pump instead?
If the house is reasonably insulated, a heat pump often gives larger running-cost and CO₂ savings, especially where electricity is not much more than three times the gas price. Compare both before replacing a boiler that will run for another 15 years.

Sources & references

  1. US DOE Energy Saver: Furnaces and Boilers
  2. US DOE Energy Savers: A Consumer's Guide to Furnaces and Boilers (PDF)
  3. IPCC 2006 Guidelines, Volume 2: Energy (CO₂ emission factors)

Embed this calculator

Free for blogs, installers, schools and NGOs. Copy the code below; it updates itself automatically.