Markets & prices guide

Fossil Fuel Subsidies Explained: Who Pays, Who Gains

Fossil fuel subsidies explained: the IEA price-gap and IMF methods, why estimates range from $620 billion to $7 trillion, who benefits and how reform works.

Updated 6 min read 1,372 words

Few energy policies are as popular, or as criticised, as fuel subsidies. Cheap petrol helps households and keeps transport costs down. It also drains public budgets, encourages waste, hands most of the benefit to people who drive the most, and works against climate goals. Malaysia has been reworking its subsidy system since 2024, so the debate is not academic here. This guide explains what counts as a subsidy, why global estimates differ by a factor of ten, who benefits, and what successful reforms have in common.

What counts as a subsidy

Governments support fossil fuels in two broad ways:

  • Consumption subsidies lower the price consumers pay. Examples: regulated pump prices below market levels, cheap electricity tariffs backed by low-cost gas for power plants, LPG sold below cost.
  • Production subsidies lower the cost of producing fuel. Examples: tax breaks for exploration, accelerated depreciation, royalty relief, cheap loans or guarantees for coal mines and pipelines.

Consumption subsidies are concentrated in fuel-exporting and middle-income countries in the Middle East, Asia, Africa and Latin America. Production support is more common in OECD countries and is tracked by the OECD’s inventory of support measures. The two often coexist.

Why estimates range from $620 billion to $7 trillion

Different organisations measure different things:

Estimate Method Latest headline figure
IEA Price gap: consumption subsidies only ~$620 billion (2023); >$1 trillion (2022)
OECD Inventory of budget transfers and tax breaks (production and consumption) in ~50 economies Several hundred billion dollars a year combined with IEA data
IMF explicit Price gap including supply costs, all fuels, all countries ~$1.3 trillion (2022)
IMF total (explicit + implicit) Also counts unpriced damage from air pollution, climate change, congestion and accidents, plus forgone consumption taxes ~$7 trillion (2022), about 7% of world GDP

The IEA price-gap approach is the narrowest: it only counts cases where consumers pay less than the market reference price. Its estimates swing with world prices. When oil and gas spiked in 2022, the gap widened and subsidies passed $1 trillion for the first time; when prices fell in 2023, they dropped by about 40%.

The IMF total is the broadest. Most of it is “implicit”: the cost to society of pollution and climate damage that fuel prices do not include. Critics argue that calling this a subsidy stretches the word. Supporters reply that it shows how far fuel prices sit from their true social cost. Both views are defensible, so always check which number someone is quoting.

How the price-gap method works

Subsidy per litre = reference price − retail price paid Total subsidy = subsidy per litre × volume sold at the subsidised price

Example (illustrative, using the BUDI95 launch prices): Reference (unsubsidised) RON95 price ≈ RM2.60/L, eligible price RM1.99/L Gap = 2.60 − 1.99 = RM0.61/L A driver using the full monthly quota of 300 L: 300 × 0.61 ≈ RM183 per month A driver using 80 L a month: 80 × 0.61 ≈ RM49 per month

The example shows the distributional problem in one line. The person who drives four times as much receives nearly four times the support. Quotas cap the transfer, which is one reason Malaysia introduced them.

Who benefits

Universal fuel subsidies are a poor way to help poor households. An IMF review of developing countries by Coady and colleagues (2015) found that the richest 20% of households captured roughly six times more of the benefit from fuel subsidies than the poorest 20%, with the gap largest for petrol. Richer families own more vehicles, drive further and use more air conditioning.

Subsidies also have side effects:

  • Fiscal cost. Spending on fuel competes with spending on health, education and infrastructure. In years of high oil prices, subsidy bills in some countries exceed health budgets.
  • Smuggling. Cheap fuel leaks across borders to neighbours with higher prices, a recurring issue on Malaysia’s borders with Thailand and Indonesia and between Nigeria and its neighbours.
  • Overconsumption and slower efficiency gains. Low prices weaken the case for efficient cars, public transport and better building design.
  • Emissions and air pollution. The IEA and IMF both estimate that removing consumption subsidies would cut global CO₂ emissions noticeably and save many lives from cleaner air.

Reform: what has worked

Indonesia (2014–2015). Soon after taking office, President Joko Widodo raised subsidised fuel prices in November 2014, then in January 2015 removed the subsidy on standard petrol and switched diesel to a fixed per-litre subsidy, helped by the oil price collapse. The savings were redirected toward infrastructure and social programmes. Subsidies crept back later as prices rose, which shows reform has to be maintained.

India (2010–2014). Petrol prices were freed in 2010 and diesel in October 2014, again timed with falling world prices. India also moved LPG subsidies to direct bank transfers, which cut fraud from duplicate and fake accounts.

Lessons from these and other cases (Iran, Egypt, Mexico, Ghana):

  • Reform when world prices are low, so the retail increase is small.
  • Phase increases in steps and announce them in advance.
  • Protect low-income households with cash transfers or targeted schemes before prices rise.
  • Explain where the savings go. Visible spending on schools, hospitals or transport builds support.
  • Introduce automatic price formulas so governments do not have to announce every change.

Failed or reversed reforms (Nigeria in 2012, Ecuador in 2019, Kazakhstan’s LPG price protests in 2022) usually raised prices sharply and suddenly without compensation in place.

Malaysia’s shift to targeted subsidies

Malaysia long used the Automatic Pricing Mechanism, with weekly prices set by the government and subsidies covering the gap to market. RON95 was held at RM2.05 per litre from 2021 to 2025, and diesel at RM2.15. Fuel subsidies cost the government roughly RM50 billion in 2022, when oil prices were high, according to Ministry of Finance statements.

Two big changes followed:

  • Diesel, June 2024. On 10 June 2024, the blanket diesel subsidy ended in Peninsular Malaysia and the price moved from RM2.15 to RM3.35 per litre, with later weekly adjustments. Eligible individuals received cash aid under the Budi Madani programme, and logistics and agriculture operators got subsidised fleet cards. Sabah, Sarawak and Labuan kept the subsidised price.
  • RON95, September 2025. Under BUDI95, from 30 September 2025, eligible Malaysian citizens buy RON95 at RM1.99 per litre by presenting MyKad at the pump, up to a monthly quota of 300 litres. Non-citizens and purchases above the quota pay the unsubsidised price, which was about RM2.60 at launch.

Details and the latest prices are on the Malaysia fuel prices page, and international comparisons on the fuel prices page. If you are weighing a car purchase, the EV vs petrol car calculator shows how subsidised petrol changes the comparison. Background on the fuels themselves is in petrol vs diesel vs LPG.

Subsidies and the energy transition

Subsidy reform sits at the centre of global climate pledges. G20 leaders promised in 2009 to phase out “inefficient fossil fuel subsidies that encourage wasteful consumption”, and the 2021 Glasgow Climate Pact repeated the call. Progress has been slow, because subsidies tend to rise exactly when prices spike and voters feel the pain.

Clean energy also receives support, through tax credits, feed-in tariffs and auctions, and a fair comparison counts both sides. The difference is direction: most clean energy subsidies are designed to decline as costs fall, while fossil consumption subsidies grow with world prices. Carbon pricing is the opposite tool, adding the climate cost to fuel prices; see carbon pricing explained.

The bottom line

  • Subsidy estimates range from about $620 billion (IEA, explicit consumption subsidies, 2023) to about $7 trillion (IMF, including unpriced damage, 2022). Check the definition.
  • The price-gap method compares retail prices with a market reference; its totals swing with oil and gas prices.
  • Universal subsidies mostly help richer households. Targeted cash or quota schemes reach the poor at lower cost.
  • Reforms work best when phased, announced, compensated and timed with low world prices.
  • Malaysia moved diesel to market pricing in Peninsular Malaysia in 2024 and RON95 to a targeted MyKad-based subsidy in 2025.

See how oil prices feed into pump prices in how the oil price is set and check the Malaysia country profile for its energy mix.

Calculators for this topic

Frequently asked questions

How big are fossil fuel subsidies?
It depends on the definition. The IEA's price-gap method put consumption subsidies at about $620 billion in 2023, down from more than $1 trillion in 2022 when fuel prices spiked. The IMF, which also counts unpriced pollution and climate damage, estimated about $7 trillion in 2022, of which around $1.3 trillion were explicit subsidies.
What is the price-gap method?
The price-gap method compares what consumers pay for a fuel with a reference price that reflects the full cost of supply, usually the international market price plus transport, distribution and normal taxes. The gap multiplied by consumption gives the subsidy. If domestic prices are at or above the reference, the measured subsidy is zero.
Who benefits most from fuel subsidies?
Mostly richer households, because they own more cars, use more electricity and buy more fuel. IMF studies across developing countries found that the richest fifth of households receives several times more benefit from petrol and diesel subsidies than the poorest fifth. Targeted cash transfers reach the poor more efficiently.
How does Malaysia subsidise petrol?
Since 30 September 2025, Malaysia sells RON95 petrol at RM1.99 per litre to eligible Malaysian citizens under the BUDI95 scheme, verified with MyKad and subject to a monthly quota. Others pay an unsubsidised price, which was about RM2.60 per litre at launch. RON97 and diesel in Peninsular Malaysia follow market-based weekly prices.
What happened to diesel prices in Malaysia in 2024?
On 10 June 2024, the government ended the blanket diesel subsidy in Peninsular Malaysia and the pump price moved from RM2.15 to RM3.35 per litre, later following weekly market adjustments. Eligible individuals, farmers and logistics operators received cash aid or fleet cards. Sabah, Sarawak and Labuan kept the subsidised price.
Why are subsidies hard to remove?
Fuel prices are highly visible and affect transport, food and almost every business cost. Sudden increases have triggered protests in countries from Nigeria to Ecuador and Kazakhstan. Successful reforms usually phase changes in gradually, explain them in advance, and protect poor households with cash transfers or targeted schemes.

Sources & references

  1. IEA — Fossil Fuel Subsidies database and methodology
  2. IMF (2023). Black, S. et al. — IMF Fossil Fuel Subsidies Data: 2023 Update
  3. OECD — Inventory of Support Measures for Fossil Fuels
  4. Coady, D., Flamini, V., Sears, L. (2015). The Unequal Benefits of Fuel Subsidies Revisited. IMF Working Paper 15/250
  5. Ministry of Finance Malaysia — BUDI95 targeted RON95 subsidy
  6. data.gov.my — Weekly fuel prices (CC BY 4.0)

Figures in this guide are typical ranges drawn from the sources above; your own numbers depend on location, prices and equipment. Use the linked calculators for site-specific estimates.